Blow out study

A

al chernoff

New member
Oct 11, 1999
737
0
0
Don't know if they were D or E. Just because they were old I replaced
them... can't help the issue of e or d .

> Al,
> I take it was a D rated tire. Right? Has anyone, anywhere had a blowout
> with E rated tires? Haven't had one response on them yet. Surely,
> somewhere, somebody has had at least one.
>
> As for D tires now, with just 25 blowouts reporting, I do believe I would
> only travel as far as necessary to the nearest tire shop to replace them
> with E's, any kind of E's.
>
> Roger
 
For those who sent in information before the compilation started, please
resend as much info as you have on your blowouts.
Got Dave's, Emery's, and Ron's with complete info.

Thanks,
Roger
 
Al,
I take it was a D rated tire. Right? Has anyone, anywhere had a blowout
with E rated tires? Haven't had one response on them yet. Surely,
somewhere, somebody has had at least one.

As for D tires now, with just 25 blowouts reporting, I do believe I would
only travel as far as necessary to the nearest tire shop to replace them
with E's, any kind of E's.

Roger
 
my .02c. When I bought my coach, went on a trip. Came home and all was well.
My son came and said, what happened to the spare. Well, I was blown away, and
so was the spare. Not being on the coach, not being under pressure, not being
anything, it blew up. The steel was showing in great profusion, and the tire
was destroyed. Went to Osburn and asked him to look at the tire. He said,
"Michelin," I said "yes," he said "blew up" and I said "yes." He said, "happens
to Michelins." They were 6 years old and at San Antonio int rally an expert
told us that any tire over 6 years old, scrap or else. They get sun, wind, etc.
and the ultraviolet wears them out. So, I went out and got new set of G159.
Went with 235/85/ which are a wide tire and I like the look of a wide tire. Had
to get a mod for the speedometer, but that was worth it. So, in response to
blow out study, put me down for one spare.
al

> Roger
> Right rear, Cooper D rated, no warning. Did not blow just seperation buldge 3
> yrs old
> Right middle, Cooper D rated, visually caught it. 3 yrs old
> Left front Cooper D rated, seperated (115 degree temp ) again about 3 yrs old
> Total tire problems in about 165K
> Justin
 
Remember that those Michelins are not the same as the new Michelin XPS ribs.
The XPS ribs are a very nice tire and I have not heard of anyone having a
problem with them. I have to stick up for Michelin since they replaced all 7
of my 14 year old tires when two blew out. Two of them they gave me, and
the other 5 at 50% off. Hows that for a warranty?

>my .02c. When I bought my coach, went on a trip. Came home and all was well.
>My son came and said, what happened to the spare. Well, I was blown away, and
>so was the spare. Not being on the coach, not being under pressure, not being
>anything, it blew up. The steel was showing in great profusion, and the tire
>was destroyed. Went to Osburn and asked him to look at the tire. He said,
>"Michelin," I said "yes," he said "blew up" and I said "yes." He said,
"happens
>to Michelins." They were 6 years old and at San Antonio int rally an expert
>told us that any tire over 6 years old, scrap or else. They get sun, wind,
etc.
>and the ultraviolet wears them out. So, I went out and got new set of G159.
>Went with 235/85/ which are a wide tire and I like the look of a wide tire.
Had
>to get a mod for the speedometer, but that was worth it. So, in response to
>blow out study, put me down for one spare.
>al
>

>
>> Roger
>> Right rear, Cooper D rated, no warning. Did not blow just seperation buldge 3
>> yrs old
>> Right middle, Cooper D rated, visually caught it. 3 yrs old
>> Left front Cooper D rated, seperated (115 degree temp ) again about 3 yrs old
>> Total tire problems in about 165K
>> Justin
>
>
 
How many total miles E's vs D's I wonder.
If my milage is any indication: 220k+ on D's ( one flat ), 5k on E's.

Makes one wonder if the the only reason no E's in the picture is that not
enough milage and age accumulated.

Heinz

> Tom,
> All of the figures are on D rated tires. No problems with E's so far.
>
> Roger
>
>
 
I had one on the right front rear axle.

Paul Bartz

From: rblack
Sent: 11/9/99 10:32 PM

Al,
I take it was a D rated tire. Right? Has anyone, anywhere had a blowout
with E rated tires? Haven't had one response on them yet. Surely,
somewhere, somebody has had at least one.

As for D tires now, with just 25 blowouts reporting, I do believe I
would
only travel as far as necessary to the nearest tire shop to replace them
with E's, any kind of E's.

Roger
 
Ran a set of michelin "D"s for 7 years and 20,000 miles with no problems.
Now have Michelin "E"s(225/75/16) with 5.000 and no problems.
Jerry
 
Al,
Tell me more about the G159 85/235. Any problem with clearance with rear bag
deflatged?? Does it rub on anything in a sharp turn? What pressure are you
running? How does the ride compare with the former? How does the traction
compare? TIA
Gary
North Bend Oregon Coast (Lots of rain)

> my .02c. When I bought my coach, went on a trip. Came home and all was well.
> My son came and said, what happened to the spare. Well, I was blown away, and
> so was the spare. Not being on the coach, not being under pressure, not being
> anything, it blew up. The steel was showing in great profusion, and the tire
> was destroyed. Went to Osburn and asked him to look at the tire. He said,
> "Michelin," I said "yes," he said "blew up" and I said "yes." He said, "happens
> to Michelins." They were 6 years old and at San Antonio int rally an expert
> told us that any tire over 6 years old, scrap or else. They get sun, wind, etc.
> and the ultraviolet wears them out. So, I went out and got new set of G159.
> Went with 235/85/ which are a wide tire and I like the look of a wide tire. Had
> to get a mod for the speedometer, but that was worth it. So, in response to
> blow out study, put me down for one spare.
> al
>

>
> > Roger
> > Right rear, Cooper D rated, no warning. Did not blow just seperation buldge 3
> > yrs old
> > Right middle, Cooper D rated, visually caught it. 3 yrs old
> > Left front Cooper D rated, seperated (115 degree temp ) again about 3 yrs old
> > Total tire problems in about 165K
> > Justin
 
Don Wirth, who worked for Goodyear for 30+years and was at the international in San
Antonio. He recommended the bigger tires, given that they had a better footprint.
When I installed them I noticed that they are real tight, and if all the air is out
of the air bags, they will go real close to touching. I don't know if they will
touch, but it was close. As to pressures, Don told me to put 65 in front and 60 in
rear. The front is heavier and needed a little more air. I have had them for some
time and am very happy with them. I did have to have a special adapter for the speed
to make up the difference in the wheels.

thanks for the question Garry.... hope all is well with you. Thanks for all the
help.
al

> Al,
> Tell me more about the G159 85/235. Any problem with clearance with rear bag
> deflatged?? Does it rub on anything in a sharp turn? What pressure are you
> running? How does the ride compare with the former? How does the traction
> compare? TIA
> Gary
> North Bend Oregon Coast (Lots of rain)
>

>
> > my .02c. When I bought my coach, went on a trip. Came home and all was well.
> > My son came and said, what happened to the spare. Well, I was blown away, and
> > so was the spare. Not being on the coach, not being under pressure, not being
> > anything, it blew up. The steel was showing in great profusion, and the tire
> > was destroyed. Went to Osburn and asked him to look at the tire. He said,
> > "Michelin," I said "yes," he said "blew up" and I said "yes." He said, "happens
> > to Michelins." They were 6 years old and at San Antonio int rally an expert
> > told us that any tire over 6 years old, scrap or else. They get sun, wind, etc.
> > and the ultraviolet wears them out. So, I went out and got new set of G159.
> > Went with 235/85/ which are a wide tire and I like the look of a wide tire. Had
> > to get a mod for the speedometer, but that was worth it. So, in response to
> > blow out study, put me down for one spare.
> > al
> >

> >
> > > Roger
> > > Right rear, Cooper D rated, no warning. Did not blow just seperation buldge 3
> > > yrs old
> > > Right middle, Cooper D rated, visually caught it. 3 yrs old
> > > Left front Cooper D rated, seperated (115 degree temp ) again about 3 yrs old
> > > Total tire problems in about 165K
> > > Justin
 
Can't remember the tires... think they were made in late 1980s, around 1997 or
8. Because when I bought my coach in 1995 they were 5 to six years old.
Sorry, having senior moment remembering.
al

>
> >>
>
> Hi Al,
>
> Was this a 16.5" tire? There was a bad Michelin that had that reputation
> some time ago. I don't think the new 16" all-steel E-rated Michelins are in
> that category.
>
> Have you noticed Roger's survey, so far, shows only failures for D-rated
> tires?
>
> Glenn
> 78 Kingsley II
> Independence, OR
 
The only comment I can add to what I said before, is that I had a tire cover on
the spare, and I use the term loosly. I had, because after the tire blew, the
cover was shredded.
al

> Roger - reading Al's reply about the spare blowing out reminded me that the
> same thing happened to me. About four years ago I had my second blowout with
> the Load Range D Michelins and so I purchased my Goodyear G159s Load Range E
> and picked the best looking Michelin Rib load range D to use as a spare. It
> was about four years old. I have to store my GMC outside and I had the spare
> facing south. About two months after putting on the new tires, I went out
> one day and found that the spare tire was shredded with pieces of wire
> sidewall sticking out all over the place. I called the tire company and
> accused them of not taking off my blown out spare and putting the good tire
> in its place. They echoed what Osborne told Al. They will self destruct due
> to the ultraviolet light breaking down the rubber. We do have a lot of sun
> in New Mexico. If you have a tire cover, keep it in place.
>
> Emery Stora
> 77 Kingsley
> Santa Fe, NM
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Applied GMC
Get your shine on at www.cruzingear.co

Share this page

Share this page
Top Bottom
Back