Palmtops vs. HPCs

gary thurlow

New member
Oct 13, 1998
21
0
0
I gotta do it. Heinz, apologies in advance. Palmtops IMHO are the AOL for
the masses who just can't seem to program their VCRs.

I purchased the orignal USR Palm Pilot _and_ the original Cassiopeia A-11
(one each Palmtop and HPC-Handheld Personal Computer) when they first
arrived. I now have an HP 660LX which _almost_ duplicates what I can do
with a full sized machine.

You seem (as do a lot of people, so you're not alone) to have a passionate
distaste for Bill Gates and, by default, Microsoft. This sounds like a
foreigner "slamming" the United States because of Bill Clinton. It just
isn't fair.

MS Windows and its derivatives have brought computing to millions of
people. Although I personally preferred OS/2, it just wasn't "right" for
the masses.

As to the Palmtops versus HPCs - my HPC came with 32 megs of RAM, 8 megs of
ROM which stores the operating system, MS Word, Excel, Powerpoint, Internet
Explorer, calendar, task list, contact manager, and fax software. Hardware
includes a 640x240 color display, docking/recharging cradle, 56K fax modem,
serial and infared printer port, flash card memory slot, and Type II PC
card slot. I use Intellisync to keep my laptop computer, desktop computer
and my HPC synchronized. You've mentioned (below) the features of the
Palmtop.

Maybe I'm a tinkerer and out of touch with how "normal" people use their
computers, but I must say that I prefer to have something that I can modify
to work the way I want it to work.

You say that you have Lotus - I am guessing that you mean Lotus 1-2-3.
What is it that 1-2-3 can do that Excel can't do? Lotus was GREAT for us
in the 1980's but I'm afraid it just hasn't kept up with the times. I
re-evaluated it for my company just last year in comparison with the MS
Office suite and the Borland Office suite. There was such a skew in
functionality that we performed our camparisons with the expressed intent
of minimizing the advantages that Microsoft's suite had. It still didn't
matter. As much as people may dislike Bill Gates, the software works
inuitively and shares CUA (common user access) which the others just can't
seem to get.

Your HP 9000's are great engineering machines with super user interfaces.
I cannot argue with anything you say about them. Except to say that Xerox
did the user interface first. Both Apple and Microsoft (and everyone else)
liberally copied from the original design specs.

And now, apologies to everyone else - I left all the original quoted
material attached to this message to show the thought flow.

The bottom line is this: get what works for you. If you are more
comfortable with a Plamtop (the best of breed is still probably the the
3Com Palm III), by all means, get it and enjoy (street price of about
$350). On the other hand, if you want something with a keyboard and
stylus/pen touch screen that looks and functions the same as your desktop
or laptop computer, you should consider the HP 620LX or 660LX (both are
color). My advice would be to stay away from the monochrome displays. They
are all very difficult to read in any type of backlit situation.

>It's the 'or'. The palmtop is how a computer should work as far as this type
>stuff operates. With the PCMCIA slot & COM slot & IR port it has most bases
>covered. It is not a CE or windows. I have five computers - 3 HP-9000's;
>this is an HP Pavilion and the palmtop. The 9000's are for engineers and
>still 2 light years ahead of Bill Gates. The MS BS (I'm running W-95) is
>crap. I get upset with this stuff. The 9000's were ahead of this 15 yrs ago.
>I'll get off my soap box. I just feel sorry for Thomsa Crapper the inventor
>of the modern tollit.
>
>Apart from my ranting - hey they let me out on the weekends. I haven't
>figured out how to get out of the white jacket yet. The MS stuff does do a
>lot for $4K and that's why I'm using it. I have Lotus (good) & MS Office pro
>edition (bad) + around $25K of software in this little unit. It does a lot
>for the money and is good for the money. That's why Bill G has
>$65,000,000,000.02.
>
>I hope you're not sorry you asked.
>-----Original Message-----
>From: Heinz Wittenbecher
>To: gmcmotorhome
>Date: Saturday, October 31, 1998 8:58 AM
>Subject: Re: GMC: GPS
>
>
>>Sam, are you referring to the HPC (LX Series) running CE 2.0
>>(HandhelpPersonalComputer) or do they have a Palmto a'la USR/3Com Palm
>>Pilot,except for running CE?
>>
>>Heinz
>>
>>
>>-----Original Message-----
>>From: Samuel Pickens
>>To: gmcmotorhome
>>Date: Saturday, October 31, 1998 4:28 AM
>>Subject: Re: GMC: GPS
>>
>>
>>>To any road warrior out there: I recommend a Hewlett Packard Palmtop
>>>computer no matter how many computers you have. They are loaded. Not only
>>do
>>>they fit in your shirt pocket but they are a full computer. I can send a
>>fax
>>>while driving down the road or get onto the Internet. And it has 1-2-3,
>>>Quicken, word processing, Data Base, printing IR, PCMCIA, COM
>port --
>>>the list goes on. It goes with you. Also used to set up engine programs
>>>(curves, timing, etc)
>>>-----Original Message-----
>>>From: Gcbr
>>>To: gmcmotorhome
>>>Date: Friday, October 30, 1998 9:17 PM
>>>Subject: Re: GMC: GPS
>>>
>>>
>>>>Patrick
>>>>
>>>>The software is even a better buy. The stuff that is proprietary is very
>>>>expensive. Talked to DeLorme the other day they said they are working
>>>>on making their software usable under Windows CE. Sure would be
>>>>cheaper than a laptop
>>>>
>>>>Take Care
>>>>Arch 76 GB IL
>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>> > Well, that is enough so you can see how and what GPS is. I still
>like
>>>my
>>>>> > DeLorme unit the best.
>>>>>
>>>>> I agree, bang for the buck the little Tripmate is tough to beat!
>>>>>
>>>>
>>>
>>
>
>
>
- ----------------------------------'
Gary Thurlow
email to thurlow
St. Louis, MO
- ----------------------------------'
 
I seem to recall that GPIB was orig HPIB due to the fact that HP invented
it. It conforms to the ISO standard. So we do like our toys.
minus all the other mail. Thank you.
 
Sorry about not including the price, Lanier! MSRP is $899 for the HP
660LX, with street prices around $850 while the 620LX is about $700 on the
street. The best comparison shopping you can do (again IMHO) is through
the ZDNet's ComputerShopper site. The address is:
http://www.zdnet.com/computershopper/

Once you're there, select "Shop by Category" and select "Handheld". You
will be shown lots of different vendors with lots of different prices.

By the way, this holds true not only for the handhelds. You can comparison
shop for almost all computer supplies on that site.

One of the nifty things about the ZDNet is that there is a small (very
small) button that says something like "ZD Reviews" when displaying
products. Click on it and you'll get the full text versions of reviews and
articles about that type of product from Ziff-Davis publishing.

While on the subject of good places for information on handheld computers
and other mobile computing stuff, check out the following two sites:

Mobile Planet's CE Central at http://www.cecentral.com/ This site has
loads of technical information and great links to manufacturer's websites.

- -and-

HPCNet Site at http://www.hpc.net/ This site also has LOTS of ads for
used handheld devices including the HPs we've been discussing.

Here are a couple of the ads:

HP-620LX includes MegaHertz 33.6 cellular capable modem. Software includes
copies of Calligrapher, Pocket On-Schedule, Pocket BizCalc, CommanCE,
eWallet, and much more. Includes all original accessories, documentation,
and packaging. I will pay for FedEx shipping anywhere in the U.S. $550
firm. Call 650-691-9400 ask for Warren or email me at murrr
Contact: Warren Murray
Email: murrr
Phone: 650-691-9400
Date: 10/14/98 9:27:39 AM
- -------------------------
HP 660LX for sale Brand New All accessories (a/c cable, dock, CDs) 56K
PCMCIA modem 16Meg Compact Flash Card $800/obo email if interested
Contact: Michael Reuter
Email: j-m
Phone:
Date: 10/13/98 9:47:06 AM
- ---------------------------

Best of luck!

>In a message dated 98-10-31 12:06:11 EST, you write:
>
>> HP 620LX or 660LX
>How Much $$$???
>Lanier

- ----------------------------------'
Gary Thurlow
email to thurlow
St. Louis, MO
- ----------------------------------'
 
My apologies if this ends up on the list twice, but I couldn't let all that
rambling go to waste (though someone will probably tell me different).

(Got screwed up borrowing someones computer... thought it was going to be
easy. Should'a known better dealing with computers. Mail prog used the
computer owners address instead of the one it was told to use :-). Just
another MS suttlety [g])

>
>-----Original Message-----
>From: Bill Bergman

>I gotta do it. Heinz, apologies in advance. Palmtops IMHO are the AOL
>for
>the masses who just can't seem to program their VCRs.
>>>

No apologies necessary.

My 2 cents...

I play with Microsoft (and do some work on/with MS) but earn my bread and
butter (and toys) with UNIX.

You 'have' to give Bill ( Gates ) credit... if it wasn't for his luck,
forsight or whatever, we'd still be in the stone ages with reference to
computers for the masses.
That doesn't mean you have to like the guy, but lets face it, most of the
folks that are pi..ed at Gates, including the lawyers that are after his
hide are just jealous they're not in his shoes.

I'll tell you one thing... If I was in his shoes I wouldn't put up with all
the sh.t and I'd take my sandbox and go were I'd be welcomed. Isn't free
enterprise supposed to work for everyone? How come it doesn't seem to work
for you once you get successful at it?

Sorry about the ramble... let's get back to important stuff, toys.
Aside from UNIX stuff, I use a Laptop (on my 3rd one), USR Palm Pilot, HP
LX620 and now a
Rex. They all have their place and usefullness and thanks to MS success
they all talk to each other as many many folks are working on/with 'neat
stuff'
in the MS Windows world. I doubt we'd have GPS's for under $200 if that
wasn't
so.

I don't particularily like windows, but now that I'm running a 300mhz PII
with an Apple flatscreen in the front and one in the back, it makes for a
nice environment for the co-pilot's duties (Mapping, Engine Monitoring,
etc). BTW, GPS satelite aquisition is much faster than with Pentium 233
Laptop.

The HP LX620 ( I bought too early again :-) is a nice HPC. The Palm Pilot
is great as it fits in the shirt pocket, but it's going to get retired in
favor of HPC and Rex. My biggest complaint about the PalmPilot is/was
resolution.
Hard to read unless light was just right. LX620/660 are color and they are
GREAT.

The new Delorme stuff (and others) now have CE portions so that you can
download a map that you cut on the lap/desktop computer.

BTW, this was (is) my first full trip with my new computer-copilot and I
encountered all kinds of lighting conditions. The Apple display came
through with flying colors including in sunlight with sunglassed on. Hefty
price
tag (1299), but they'll come down. There is just no words to explain the
difference between laptop screen and apple. Needs the room etc, but I'm
glad I did it. (May not be next time I have to lift the doghouse).

Sorry for the ramble... but I'm going to send it anyways :-)

Heinz
'76 Transmode
mailstop in Stockton, CA --> Lvegas NV.

P.S. Folks using GPS that know their speedo is accurate: How accurate is
the groundspeed from the GPS? I consistently show about 3mph higher on the
GPS.
Guess it's time to check/calibrate the speedo, perhaps?
 
Heinz - I was actually the poster, not Bill Bergman (?)

Anyhow, it seems to me that we're both singing off the same sheet of music
here. I envy your Apple flatscreen - they're gorgeous! But tell me more
about the REXX. I've been thinking of getting one for their small size.
How is the software and screen readability?

Also, since you've already done it, please tell me about the difficulties
in getting the co-pilot to use the GPS together with the laptop? Would I be
underpowered in using a 166 MHz machine? (I can pick one up for pretty
cheap.) Also, do you have some special mount for this setup that prevents
everything from becoming a lethal projectile in the event of a panic stop?
I'm thinking of some sort of permanent but foldable gizmo from an old
typing stand (yegads!) that could be pushed/folded out of the way. Also, I
am not a design engineer so I am limited to something that someone else has
done.

>My apologies if this ends up on the list twice, but I couldn't let all that
>rambling go to waste (though someone will probably tell me different).
>
>(Got screwed up borrowing someones computer... thought it was going to be
>easy. Should'a known better dealing with computers. Mail prog used the
>computer owners address instead of the one it was told to use :-). Just
>another MS suttlety [g])
>
>
>>I gotta do it. Heinz, apologies in advance. Palmtops IMHO are the AOL
>>for
>>the masses who just can't seem to program their VCRs.
>>>>
>
>
>No apologies necessary.
>
>My 2 cents...
>
>I play with Microsoft (and do some work on/with MS) but earn my bread and
>butter (and toys) with UNIX.
>
>Sorry about the ramble... let's get back to important stuff, toys.
>Aside from UNIX stuff, I use a Laptop (on my 3rd one), USR Palm Pilot, HP
>LX620 and now a
>Rex. They all have their place and usefullness and thanks to MS success
>they all talk to each other as many many folks are working on/with 'neat
>stuff'
>in the MS Windows world. I doubt we'd have GPS's for under $200 if that
>wasn't
>so.
>
>I don't particularily like windows, but now that I'm running a 300mhz PII
>with an Apple flatscreen in the front and one in the back, it makes for a
>nice environment for the co-pilot's duties (Mapping, Engine Monitoring,
>etc). BTW, GPS satelite aquisition is much faster than with Pentium 233
>Laptop.
>
>
>BTW, this was (is) my first full trip with my new computer-copilot and I
>encountered all kinds of lighting conditions. The Apple display came
>through with flying colors including in sunlight with sunglassed on. Hefty
>price
>tag (1299), but they'll come down. There is just no words to explain the
>difference between laptop screen and apple. Needs the room etc, but I'm
>glad I did it. (May not be next time I have to lift the doghouse).
>

- ----------------------------------'
Gary Thurlow
email to thurlow
St. Louis, MO
- ----------------------------------'
 
Arch...

Sounds very good to me... but,

> lose the signal in cities tunnels ect.

I understand tunnels, but it is the etc. that I am interested in. How
about tall buildings or a series of tall buildings. Have you tried it in
the hills or small mountain foothills? How about bridges with
superstructures? Thanks...
- --
Regards,
John 74 Glacier near Washington, DC.
 
>about the REXX. I've been thinking of getting one for their small size.
>How is the software and screen readability?

Readability is good (not as good as my old,old Sharp Wizard was, but good.
It basically duplicated address book, notes, task, etc from the lap or
desktop.
With the REX-Pro you can key stuff in, but it's painstaking.

It's the size... I'm hoping that I can get it to the point were all
important addresses, notes, etc get synced to it.
The PalmPilot is good too, but I found that I used it very little to enter
stuff into so the REX may do same in smaller package.

>
>Also, since you've already done it, please tell me about the difficulties
>in getting the co-pilot to use the GPS together with the laptop? Would I be
>underpowered in using a 166 MHz machine?

A 166 is no problem. Until recently I used a 50mhz 486 Laptop for GPS, etc.
and it was just fine too. Might take a little longer to lock onto Satelites
initially, but I find that that's more a function of the receiver anyways.

Be sure to get a 12volt adapter for the GPS, i.e. power from other than
AA's. The initial TripMate was battery and 12volt an option. Get the option.
Perhaps it's already standard by now.

< (I can pick one up for pretty
>cheap.) Also, do you have some special mount for this setup that prevents
>everything from becoming a lethal projectile in the event of a panic stop?

I used a TV wallmount adapted to a mount to the cabinet. I use the no slip
cloth for everything. As the stuff is next to me or ahead of me I havn't
worried about it too much re projectile. If it start flying around it's
probably serious+ :-)

Stuff behind me I use velcro and/or bungies.



Heinz
the only soul in a KOA in Utah :) eerie....
 
Heinz...

> Heinz
> the only soul in a KOA in Utah :) eerie....

I didn't know you could Shine...

- --
Regards,
John 74 Glacier near Washington, DC.