Follow-up, first time out

neely butler

New member
Sep 28, 1998
204
0
0
Still have sewer holding tank problems after many flushings and feeble
checking. Called new place in Nashville (Camper's Corner), asked for
estimate to remove, repair, and replace tank. Answer, $600 to $700. Is this
this reasonable???Have not called Camping World as yet.
Neely B. Tenn
'78 Eleganza II
 
I redid my holding tank. New tank from ARDEMCO (advertises in GMCMM) was
$240. Upgrade to Macerator pump $65. New stiainless bolt/nuts that hold
tank to bottom $20

>Still have sewer holding tank problems after many flushings and feeble
>checking. Called new place in Nashville (Camper's Corner), asked for
>estimate to remove, repair, and replace tank. Answer, $600 to $700. Is this
>this reasonable???Have not called Camping World as yet.
>Neely B. Tenn
>'78 Eleganza II
>
 
Thorm,
Thanks for your reply. Called Cinnabar Engr, price for new tank $350. plus
$90. shipping. Hope I will not need new tank. Local shop says labor
should not be more that $300--$400 plus parts and sure they can repair old
if needed. Where are you??
Neely B. Tenn
- -----Original Message-----
From: Thom Hole
To: gmcmotorhome
Date: Friday, February 12, 1999 3:00 PM
Subject: Re: GMC: Follow-up, first time out

>I redid my holding tank. New tank from ARDEMCO (advertises in GMCMM) was
>$240. Upgrade to Macerator pump $65. New stiainless bolt/nuts that hold
>tank to bottom $20
>
>

>>Still have sewer holding tank problems after many flushings and feeble
>>checking. Called new place in Nashville (Camper's Corner), asked for
>>estimate to remove, repair, and replace tank. Answer, $600 to $700. Is
this
>>this reasonable???Have not called Camping World as yet.
>>Neely B. Tenn
>>'78 Eleganza II
>>
>
>
 
Neely........For 700 dollars, I'd do one hell of a lot of flushing and
fiddling. Get back out there and stay with it until you find the problem.
It just can't be that complicated.........Jim Davis 77 Coca Cola, Oregon
Coast

- -----Original Message-----
From: Neely Butler [SMTP:Neely.Butler]
Sent: Friday, February 12, 1999 9:08 AM
To: GMC chat
Subject: GMC: Follow-up, first time out

Still have sewer holding tank problems after many flushings and feeble
checking. Called new place in Nashville (Camper's Corner), asked for
estimate to remove, repair, and replace tank. Answer, $600 to $700. Is
this
this reasonable???Have not called Camping World as yet.
Neely B. Tenn
'78 Eleganza II
 
Hay Jim,
Thanks a bunch for the concern and comments you and all the others have
expressed for my problems. After talking to so many others and analyzing my
own efforts I now feel assured that the problem is that one of the vents at
the point where it enters the tank has fractured or is otherwise leaking at
that point. The tank must be removed regardless. Guess I will go to a
local shop and let them "have-at-it". Thanks again all.
Neely B. Tenn
- -----Original Message-----
From: Jim Davis
To: 'gmcmotorhome'
Date: Friday, February 12, 1999 6:15 PM
Subject: RE: GMC: Follow-up, first time out

>Neely........For 700 dollars, I'd do one hell of a lot of flushing and
>fiddling. Get back out there and stay with it until you find the problem.
>It just can't be that complicated.........Jim Davis 77 Coca Cola, Oregon
>Coast
>
>-----Original Message-----
>From: Neely Butler [SMTP:Neely.Butler]
>Sent: Friday, February 12, 1999 9:08 AM
>To: GMC chat
>Subject: GMC: Follow-up, first time out
>
>Still have sewer holding tank problems after many flushings and feeble
>checking. Called new place in Nashville (Camper's Corner), asked for
>estimate to remove, repair, and replace tank. Answer, $600 to $700. Is
>this
>this reasonable???Have not called Camping World as yet.
>Neely B. Tenn
>'78 Eleganza II
>
>
 
If your problem is in the connections into the top of the tank, they are
accessable from the top. I was haveing problems after a trip up the Dalton
highway. I broke a shock mount, and also the drain connections into the
tank. On my 73 Elaganza the sink side is accessable in the closet floor,
and in the bathroom from the bathroom wall. I was able to cut the old pipe
out and install new ones with about 2 hrs work. Total cost was less than
$10.00. Of course cleaning the garbage off the top of the tank took some
time at a local car wash.
- ----- Original Message -----
From: Neely Butler
To:
Sent: Friday, February 12, 1999 8:24 PM
Subject: Re: GMC: Follow-up, first time out

>Hay Jim,
>Thanks a bunch for the concern and comments you and all the others have
>expressed for my problems. After talking to so many others and analyzing
my
>own efforts I now feel assured that the problem is that one of the vents at
>the point where it enters the tank has fractured or is otherwise leaking at
>that point. The tank must be removed regardless. Guess I will go to a
>local shop and let them "have-at-it". Thanks again all.
>Neely B. Tenn
>-----Original Message-----
>From: Jim Davis
>To: 'gmcmotorhome'
>Date: Friday, February 12, 1999 6:15 PM
>Subject: RE: GMC: Follow-up, first time out
>
>
>>Neely........For 700 dollars, I'd do one hell of a lot of flushing and
>>fiddling. Get back out there and stay with it until you find the problem.
>>It just can't be that complicated.........Jim Davis 77 Coca Cola, Oregon
>>Coast
>>
>>-----Original Message-----
>>From: Neely Butler [SMTP:Neely.Butler]
>>Sent: Friday, February 12, 1999 9:08 AM
>>To: GMC chat
>>Subject: GMC: Follow-up, first time out
>>
>>Still have sewer holding tank problems after many flushings and feeble
>>checking. Called new place in Nashville (Camper's Corner), asked for
>>estimate to remove, repair, and replace tank. Answer, $600 to $700. Is
>>this
>>this reasonable???Have not called Camping World as yet.
>>Neely B. Tenn
>>'78 Eleganza II
>>
>>
>
>
 
Robert,
Took out the floor of the closet, the PVC pipe was visible, had a metal
cover over it beside the air-compressor in that compartment, removed the
cover, PVC with clean-out was accessible. A threaded ring was around the PVC
pipe as it entered the floor but it was not screwed on a connector?? It was
just loose. The pipe would slip up about 1/2 inch. A rusty ring was
attached to the floor that allowed the PVC to enter. This may be part of my
problem but could see no way to fix. In the bath, removed the cabinet with
the sliding plastic doors. The drain from the sink went past the water
heater into the wall behind the commode. No help there. Had great hopes
when I got your message but guess I am back to ground zero. Many thanks
Neely.Butler
- -----Original Message-----
From: Robert Hopper
To: gmcmotorhome
Date: Saturday, February 13, 1999 12:16 PM
Subject: Re: GMC: Follow-up, first time out

>If your problem is in the connections into the top of the tank, they are
>accessable from the top. I was haveing problems after a trip up the Dalton
>highway. I broke a shock mount, and also the drain connections into the
>tank. On my 73 Elaganza the sink side is accessable in the closet floor,
>and in the bathroom from the bathroom wall. I was able to cut the old pipe
>out and install new ones with about 2 hrs work. Total cost was less than
>$10.00. Of course cleaning the garbage off the top of the tank took some
>time at a local car wash.
>----- Original Message -----
>From: Neely Butler
>To:
>Sent: Friday, February 12, 1999 8:24 PM
>Subject: Re: GMC: Follow-up, first time out
>
>
>>Hay Jim,
>>Thanks a bunch for the concern and comments you and all the others have
>>expressed for my problems. After talking to so many others and analyzing
>my
>>own efforts I now feel assured that the problem is that one of the vents
at
>>the point where it enters the tank has fractured or is otherwise leaking
at
>>that point. The tank must be removed regardless. Guess I will go to a
>>local shop and let them "have-at-it". Thanks again all.
>>Neely B. Tenn
>>-----Original Message-----
>>From: Jim Davis
>>To: 'gmcmotorhome'
>>Date: Friday, February 12, 1999 6:15 PM
>>Subject: RE: GMC: Follow-up, first time out
>>
>>
>>>Neely........For 700 dollars, I'd do one hell of a lot of flushing and
>>>fiddling. Get back out there and stay with it until you find the problem.
>>>It just can't be that complicated.........Jim Davis 77 Coca Cola, Oregon
>>>Coast
>>>
>>>-----Original Message-----
>>>From: Neely Butler [SMTP:Neely.Butler]
>>>Sent: Friday, February 12, 1999 9:08 AM
>>>To: GMC chat
>>>Subject: GMC: Follow-up, first time out
>>>
>>>Still have sewer holding tank problems after many flushings and feeble
>>>checking. Called new place in Nashville (Camper's Corner), asked for
>>>estimate to remove, repair, and replace tank. Answer, $600 to $700. Is
>>>this
>>>this reasonable???Have not called Camping World as yet.
>>>Neely B. Tenn
>>>'78 Eleganza II
>>>
>>>
>>
>>
>